|
Back...
2007
MAJOR TROPHY SHOW JUDGES REPORT -
Mr J
Schiller [Centuria]
First
off I would like to congratulate the MTS organizing committee on putting
together once again a world class show. To the Chairman of the SABTC and
his is committee a big “WELL DONE”, the show was run to perfection
with the ring well laid out and beautifully adorned. I must at the same
time also thank the sponsor, Eukanuba and Mrs de Coning, for without their
support this prestigious event would not be the same. As far as the
after-show events are concerned, I really appreciated the clubs gift and
had a really good time at the party which was excellent, the music was
good and the food scrumptious, and again and well done guys, Bull Terriers
need this type of dedicated enthusiasm.
I
have where possible tried to comment positively and believe that my
judging style rewards virtue before penalizing faults and my report should
be taken in this light.
Judges:
A – Myself, Joe Schiller
B – Wynand Lourens
C – Louw Brits
| BEST
IMPORTED DOG: Judges : A
& B |
|
In
this class two dogs caught my eye Meakers, Barradur Prince at
Kilacabar, and Jones’s Ch Bullyview Leading Role to Navada.
Winner
– No.3 Ch Bullyview
Leading Role to Navada a heavyweight Brindle and White with a
deep, broad chest, this dog had sufficient bone and spring of rib
as well as a filled head showing good expression. Mouth level
pincer bite, canines correct. He has a level top-line and well set
tail but is a bit long in the back, on the move was square in both
directions and from the side had good drive, to be very critical I
would like to see more light under the dog and I did not like his
feet but a good Bull Terrier nevertheless. I also liked No.1 Barradur
Prince at Kilacabar, another Brindle and White with a cracker of a head, egg shaped
with plenty of power and smoothness with a small mouth fault. He
did not leave me with the impression of power as the winner did,
but a worthy contender nevertheless.
Unanimous
decision with Mr. Lourens |
| |
| ORMANDY
JUG - DOGS UNDER TWO YEARS: Judges
: A & C |
|
Winner
– No. 5 Ipon The Rock
a Black Brindle and White. A tall upstanding youngster whose long
head has a beautifully curved profile, plenty of fill and power
with a strong under-jaw, correct mouth, and his long neck flowed
into a level top-line complimented by his horizontal tail set. He
also has a deep chest and good spring of rib; close coupled and
well bent stifles, moved well in front but loose behind overall a
quality picture that I am looking forward to see mature. Another
dog worth mentioning in this class was Nicholsons Natuli
Paramount
a lovely upstanding elegant white; the winner had a better
head and deep chest that I favored though.
Unanimous
decision with Mr.Brits. |
| |
| ORMANDY
JUG - DOGS OVER TWO YEARS: Judges
: B & C |
|
I
did not judge the class but would dearly have loved to, as two
dogs caught my eye from the side of the ring, namely, No.10
Mattheys’ Ch Bukavi Diesel ‘n Dust and No.19 du Plessis
Ch Panomar Klaas Oxsan a pity these two were eliminated so
early on.
Unanimous
decision Mr Lourens and Brits to No. 17 Jones’s Ch Navada Eye
Bandit.
|
| |
| COLOURED
DOGS: Judges : A & B |
|
My
choice in this class was for du Plessis Ch Panomar Klaas Oxsan
a big, powerful red with a great depth of chest, deep and broad
brisket, good layback of shoulder, close coupled and moved well
coming but a little close behind, his head was smooth and powerful
with good fill (even if slightly lippy) and a strong under-jaw,
not a great profile but more than adequate power with well placed
prick ears and great expression with a perfect scissors bite.
Although he was a little loose in the elbow he had well bent
stifles and a horizontal tail set with compact cat-like feet which
presented a picture of quality. I chose him above his main rival
Jones’s Ch Bullyview Leading Role to Navada because of
his better layback of shoulder, shorter back and overall type,
power and substance.
Split
decision, Referee Mr. Brits’ choice Winner – No. 3 Jones’s Ch
Bullyview Leading Role to Navada. |
| |
| IMPORTED
BITCHES: |
|
None present
. |
| |
| ORMANDY
VASE - BITCHES UNDER 2 YEARS:
Judges : B & C |
| Winner
– unanimous decision, No 30 van der Merwe’s Rhihnestone Rumour
Has It of Malycwa.
|
| |
| ORMANDY
JUG - BITCHES UNDER 2 YEARS: Judges
: A & B |
|
In
this class I chose No. 35, Coetzee’s Ch Dajamani Dancing
Carla, a heavyweight upstanding bitch that has a beautiful
head filled and smooth with a correct mouth, she has plenty of
substance and bone with good spring of rib, a short back, correct
tail set and well bent stifles. Unfortunately her movement was not
her forte’ as she was close behind but adequate in front and
still had plenty of drive, preferred her due to her better
substance and size.
Split
decision, Referee Mr. Brits’ choice Winner – No. 42
Schoeman’s Ch
Stelron Iron Lady at Combolcias. |
| |
| COLOURED
BITCH - RHINESTONE SHIELD: Judges : A & C |
| Winner
– No 42 Schoeman's Ch Stelron Iron Lady of Combolcias by
unanimous decision. A tri-colour with a beautiful curved head,
smooth and free of indentations, prick ears and varminty
expression, slight mouth fault, although I prefer a broader muzzle
she is a quality animal, upstanding with a deep chest and adequate
bone, a long elegant neck, close coupled and a level top-line. I
would like to have seen a better bend of stifle and her tail-set
was a little high, nevertheless she was streets ahead of her
competitors with a head like that.
|
| |
| BEST
IMPORTED BULL TERRIER: |
|
Winner – No 3
by default as no imported bitches were present. |
| |
| BEST COLOURED BULL
TERRIER - BRILOWS TROPHY: Judges : A & B |
| Winner
– No 3 Ch Bullyview Leading Role to Navada I preferred
him to the bitch as his overall substance, size and ring presence
dominated. |
|
|
| BEST MOVER - TOM
HORNER TARTARY TROPHY: Judges : A & C |
|
Winner
– No.16 Ruppings Ch Narciano Samuel a white dog that I
also liked, he was a true mover in all respects with great length
of stride and powerful drive in the rear reaching well in front,
from the side it was a flowing picture with his top-line level,
from the front and rear he was parallel and wide.
A
unanimous decision with Mr. Brits. |
| |
| BEST HEAD -
MONTESANO TROPHY: |
| Winner
– No 3 Ch Bullyview Leading Role to Navada.
|
| |
| SABTC - DOG OF THE
YEAR: Judges : A & B |
|
My
choice in this class was for the colored dog No. 3 Jones’s Ch
Bullyview Leading Role to Navada who I preferred due to his
presence, a more powerful dog as I mention earlier with good
spring of rib, substance and bone, also moved better with a better
front and head.
Split
decision, Referee Mr Brits choice Winner – No. 17 Jones’s Ch
Navada Eye Bandit. |
| |
| SABTC - BITCH OF
THE YEAR: Judges : A & B |
| Winner
– No 30 van der
Merwe’s Ch Rhinestone Rumour Has It of Malycwa a
beautiful feminine yet substantial bitch with a lovely head,
filled and smooth, her broader muzzle, correct mouth and better
substance gave her the win, neither of the bitches were
outstanding movers but both were good examples of how a Bull
Terrier should look packed with type and quality.
A
unanimous decision with Mr Brits.
|
| |
| SA SUPREME BULL
TERRIER OF 2007 |
|
I
chose the bitch Ch Rhinestone Rumour Has It of Malycwa and
felt that she was a better bitch than Eye Bandit was a dog, with
more substance and type, better front and head quality, overall
carrying more balance and style on top of her being in top show
condition.
Winner
No. 17 Jones’s Ch Navada Eye Bandit.
|
|
|
|
In
Closing
In
all I found all male dogs to be entire with two fully descended
testicles and there were no reasons to penalize or disqualify any
exhibit due to health or other reasons.
As
a general comment I was impressed with most of the dogs exhibited
and believe that we have some of the best animals on the planet
but was quite shocked at the quality of some of the exhibits,
after all this is the showcase of Bull Terriers in South Africa
and inferior specimens of the breed should not even qualify, it
leaves me doubting the quality of judging in South Africa as on
each CC or Challenge Certificate the judge has to sign and state
that “I am clearly of the opinion that this exhibit is of such
outstanding merit as to be worthy of qualifying for the title of
Champion”. Lack of virtue and type as well as glaring faults
were so visibly evident that if this were the only or best exhibit
for me to judge I would withhold the CC, perhaps if judges of our
breed had the gumption to apply this model it would raise
standards and resolve our problems with “cheap champions” by
sending a message to other judges that they need to improve their
knowledge of our breed and judge honestly according to the breed
standard for Bull Terriers.
Yours
in Bull Terriers
Joe Schiller
Centuria Bull Terriers |
|
|
|